Is retirement an outmoded concept? by Bob Lowry


By Bob Lowry

Sometimes I wonder if the whole concept of retirement is destined for the dustbin.The idea of retiring from work is a rather new phenomenon. Some experts see it beginning around the turn of the 20th century, but it didn’t become something that most thought about until fifty or sixty years ago, with the beginning of Social Security and strong employer pensions. Certainly my parent’s generation welcomed retirement, and the majority of folks my age aspire to that part of life.But, over the last few years I have watched at least five trends that seem to raise questions about retirement’s appeal, or even viability. Consider these circumstances:

1. Savings rates can’t possibly support full retirement. For those 45-54, the median amount saved for retirement is $100,000. For 35-44 year olds, the median saved is only $61,000. Even forgetting about retirement savings for a moment, 72 million Americans have no emergency savings at all. That is a whole bunch of folks who are one paycheck away from financial hardship or ruin, much less retirement.

2. The support of company pensions has all but disappeared. The defined benefit type plan is but a fond memory for most. Companies have been cutting the contributions and scope of pension plans for the last few decades. Poorly funded 401(k) accounts, or no pension at all, are more the norm. Future generations will likely never experience the option of a robust pension.

3. The likelihood of cutbacks in Social Security benefits and means testing for payments are virtual certainties in the years to come. There are too many folks retiring and too few workers to fund their Social Security payments to keep the system operating the way it does today.

4. The amount of money needed to retire continues to rise. Thirty or forty years ago someone with one hundred thousand dollars in savings and investments, a decent pension, medical coverage, and Social Security could look forward to a comfortable retirement. Then, the “magic” figure became $500,000, quickly followed by one million dollars. Today, retirement gurus claim you need 2 million dollars to have a shot at a pleasant time away from work. Needless to say, 2 million is a number very, very few will accumulate; one million is impossible for most.

5. Maybe just as important, the interest in continuing to work is growing. Due to financial concerns (see #1 above), wanting to continue doing something that is satisfying, fearful of free time with nothing to do, or anxious to start a new business and make a lifelong  dream real, the percentage of those who say they have no plans to stop working, or working well past the typical target of 65, is increasing. Some studies show it is nearly 33% of all workers.

About a year ago I wrote a post that asked if retirement blogging was still viable. At that point several folks who focused on retirement had decided to close down their blogs, feeling that everything they had to say on the subject had been said. My question wasn’t about the future of retirement, but rather the future of retirement as a subject for a several times a week blog.

One year later, I am now wondering about the reality of retirement in the decades to come. Has our world changed to the point where retirement isn’t something the majority will ever experience, either by choice, or circumstances? Within the next few generations will retirement be as uncommon as it was 60 years ago?

What do you think?

By Bob Lowry

4 responses to “Is retirement an outmoded concept? by Bob Lowry

  1. The amount of money needed to retired has increased because rates of returns on your retirement savings has decreased. Zero % interest rates has postponed retirement, 10 year bond yields of less than 2 % is crazy. Interest rates have to go up soon or we will have to work way past 65!!!!

  2. My father’s comment on pension plans and employer-provided health insurance was that these were distortions of the market from the late 40’s. When Truman imposed price controls to combat inflation as we de-mobilized from WW II, the only way to offer “higher pay” to an employee you wanted to hire or keep was to raise the benefits.

  3. I cannot even begin to imagine going back to work full time and I have only been retired ten months. Certainly hope living frugally will extend the life of my savings, CPP and OAS. I am Canadian but no telling what will happen here as well!!

  4. “Reality of Retirement” – almost an oxymoron. I have to say that I did not have good counsel growing up and neither as an adult on the importance of saving for anything. Now, After foolishly moving from several decent retirement type jobs and cashing out the small amount to get me moved to the next shiny path and losing my last career type job with only 7k in the retirement fund, which I had to cash out to live on until I found another job, I finally arrive at age 62 with a lot of stress

    Looking to legally make a lot of money in a short amount of time will take me out of the mainstream and I am finding into the online world where many much younger online “gurus” are making a significant income. I have hired a mentor and entered the very fast paced learning environment to create the retirement income I need – the goal is 2M in 5 years. Others are doing it over and over, why not me 🙂

    I am fortunate to have good computer skills and still quick to learn new things and My hope is to get the process down and start helping other stressed out retirees check it out and use what I am learning to blast that small fixed income paradigm so they can have that coffee table retirement they always dreamed of or possibly never thought they could have.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.